Table of Contents
Written by : Tristan Reid |
Current |
Write a comment |
Write a comment
hi I'm John Rizvi the patent professor a common question I get is whether you can file for a patent on a product that is already made but that currently doesn't have a patent well in order to file for a patent you must be the inventor now if you find an existing product and you modify it or you apply it in a unique method you might be considered the inventor and you can proceed with your own patent you can also improve existing products and if your improvement is seen as being new useful and it's not an obvious variation of what already exists you could qualify for a patent some examples of obvious improvements that will not qualify are changes in size or changes in color or shape of course if there is some obstacle that you're able to overcome by changing the size for example making a hearing aid significantly smaller or it's changing the shape or color allows you to overcome an obstacle then these improvements could be seen as being non-obvious and you still might qualify if you're not sure if your improvement qualifies for a patent give me a call I'm John RISD the patent professor you
Thanks for your comment Esther Fricker, have a nice day.
- Tristan Reid, Staff Member
you have an idea for an invention but it's really just a small tiny slight change on an existing product can you move forward with that product and can you patent it stick around because you're gonna find out hi everyone I'm Alex Reid the founder of invent insight an online platform with affordable and free online courses and resources for product development and product licensing for anyone that's looking to bring his or her idea to market in this video we're going to review inventing and patenting improvements on existing products and we're gonna do this by looking at the history of a well known simple product the paperclip it's a great example of improving existing products and how patents play into that now before we get started I want you to take a guess just a guess and how many patents there are on the paperclip I think you're gonna be surprised let's go check it out here's an answer that always surprises me when I ask someone do you have an idea and they say yeah but it's really just a slight tiny change improvement on an existing product I said oh that's great lucky you because what you have is an idea to improve an existing product and that's one of the best ideas to have I also get this question a lot what if my idea is already patented can i patent something that already exists so let's take a look at that first thing is one take a look at the definite of invent create or design something that has not existed before to be the originator of but here's the example they give he invented an improved form of the steam engine so basically he improved the steam engine with something that didn't exist before and that he was the originator of so when you think of inventing improving is a big part of invention in looking at improving existing product examples my favorite is a very well known simple basic staple product the paperclip let's take a journey and check out a little history on the development the invention of the paperclip and the patenting of the paperclip this is really interesting we're on a site called the early office Museum and I've loaded up the page on the history of the paperclip there's a few things that I want to show you scroll down now this is the first one it was patented in 1867 to Samuel they now what's interesting is it's described as a clip a ticket fastener to be used in lieu of a pen to fasten tickets to find fabrics that's what this gentleman wanted to patent but what's really interesting is the patent noted could be used to attach a paper ticket to other pieces of paper so that's really where the whole paper clip started and then as you scroll down you'll see different types of clips and the date that they were patented and there's a little information over here on the history of that paper clip or the company or even their advertising it's quite a long list so I'm not going to go over every one but the one I wanted to point out the most is the gem now the gem paper clip is kind of the paper clip that we think of today we see a lot in offices it's used as standard and this was not patented but they did do a trademark for the gem paper clip so as you can see different people are coming up with improvements on the paper clip either by design material all kinds of different ways to improve the paper clip and all these patents that were awarded but I want to show you here we go this is the improved gem paper clip and it was patented in 1903 you can see it has a little bit of a lift on the lip here I scroll down a little further because I wanted to show you this all right so these are obviously three variations of the gem clip they're slight changes so this one was patented in 1921 and it says this type of clip had many equal space perpendicular serrations on the long it's only so you can see that right there and then three years later another change was patented in 1924 and it said this type of clip had fewer indentations than the Colette type clip as you can see there and then in 1927 there was another patent awarded and this type of clip had many equal space perpendicular serrations all along the wire so you can see that here and then as we know today we see paper clips with a light coating of rubber on them so somebody came up with that later on down the road but what this shows is that they're patenting a slight improvement change on an existing product so jump on this site and check it out I think you're gonna find it really interesting now let's go back to some of the questions can I patent something that already exists what if my idea is already patented I put together kind of a chart so that we can take a better look at this and of course I wanted to stay on the paperclip as being the product so let's take a look at this we'll come here with my pointer so you have Mike let's say Mike invented the gem and he patented the gem product in 1997 now Joe over here so wow I have a great idea to improve that Jim I'm gonna coat it with it's non non-skid coating and he patents that improvement for the non-skid coating in 2015 so here's what happens if the improved product is still protected by a patent then Joe can't make or sell that product with his improvement he can only patent the improvement now if that gem patent expires in 2017 which it will after 20 years it becomes public domain which means that anyone can manufacture and sell that product because it's no longer protected by the pattern so Joe can wait two years or better yet he can approach Mike and say look I've got a great idea for an improvement on your product so they can draw up a licensing agreement and it can go a couple different ways Mike can license his gem to Joe so that Joe can make it with his improvement make it and sell it with his improvement or Joe can license the nonskid improvement to Mike and that kind of is what happens a lot with inventors product designers or product developers or everyday folks that come up with improvements they all approach the Mike who has the product is manufacturing it has everything in the pipeline and they'll say hey guess what Mike I have a great idea for an improvement maybe Joe doesn't want to get into the whole manufacturing and starting a business he was just clever enough to come up with a great improvement on a product but Mike that's an advantage to have an improvement on his product so most likely Mike will license that improvement from Joe and that's what's so great about licensing improvements on existing products because basically really Joe just needed to file a provisional patent application for $70 do some of his due diligence then also get his concept in presentation mode format and call up Mike and say hey I've already started the patenting process but here here's my improvement are you interested now remember when we looked at the office museum - the gem paperclip was never patented and even if it had been it would have long been expired and that's why we saw all these improvements on the gem paperclip and once it's in the public domain like I said anyone can make and market the core product with the improvement now before we wrap up I want you to remember the question I asked you
Thanks Joshua your participation is very much appreciated
- Tristan Reid
About the author
I've studied social development at California State University, Northridge in Northridge and I am an expert in public policy. I usually feel drained. My previous job was benefits manager I held this position for 31 years, I love talking about skiing and whale watching. Huge fan of Anthony Joshua I practice gymnastics: rhythmic and collect collectible card games.
Try Not to laugh !
Joke resides here...